Skip to main content
Testing. You are viewing the public testing version of GCN. For the production version, go to
New Announcement Feature, Code of Conduct, Circular Revisions. See news and announcements

GCN Circular 12170

Swift J1822.3-1606: Transient Magnetar or Be X-ray Binary?
2011-07-18T23:39:04Z (13 years ago)
Jules Halpern at Columbia U. <>
Gogus et al. (GCN 12167) and Gorosabel et al. (ATel #3496)
have proposed that the recently detected 8.43 s pulsar
Swift J1822.3-1606 (Cummings et al., GCN 12159) may be a
transient Be/X-ray binary like the 15.3 s pulsar Swift J1626.6-5156,
rather than a magnetar.  These suggestions were motivated by the
large pulsed fraction of 41%, and a candidate 2MASS IR counterpart
in the 1.8" radius X-ray error circle (as refined by Pagani et al.,
ATel #3493).  However, the relatively small X-ray column of
3e21 cm^-2 for a power-law plus blackbody fit (Esposito et al.,
ATel #3490), together with the colors of the 2MASS star and lack
of a bright optical detection, are incompatible with a B star companion.

The intrinsic colors of an early B star, for example, type B1V,
are J-K = -0.14, V-K = -0.76.  In contrast, the 2MASS candidate
has K = 11.63, J-K = 2.43, and V-K > 9 (from its absence on
red and blue Sky Survey plates).  The implied color excess
E(V-K) > 10 for a B star is inconsistent with the X-ray column
density 3e21 cm^-2, the latter corresponding to only ~1.7 magnitudes
of extinction in V.  A B1V star of absolute magnitude M_V = -3.14
at an assumed distance of 3 kpc should then have apparent V ~ 10.9,
which is strongly contradicted by the non-detection.  (See Reig et al.,
arXiv:1106.4671, for analogous discussion of the actual V = 15.5 optical
counterpart of Swift J1626.6-5156, which has 3 times larger X-ray
column than Swift J1822.3-1606.)

Instead, the X-ray properties of Swift J1822.3-1606 may be similar
to those of the 2003 outburst of the transient AXP XTE J1810-197
(Gotthelf & Halpern 2007, Ap&SS, 308, 79), including the latter's
initial 2-10 keV flux of ~1e-10 erg cm^-2 s^-1, initial pulsed fraction
of ~50%, X-ray column density of 6e21 cm^-2, distance of 3-4 kpc
(Minter et al. 2008, ApJ, 676, 1189), and short (~1 s) bursts
(Woods et al. 2005, ApJ, 629, 985).
Looking for U.S. government information and services? Visit